DISCLAIMER

Dr Don is NOT a medical professional, nor is he a psychiatrist or qualified psychologist.

Dr Don holds a Doctorate of Philosophy and is entitled to the use of the prefix Dr. He has however many years of life experience, education, employment history and relationships and this is what his advice is based upon.

ANY advice given here that you wish to consider or follow IS AT YOUR OWN RISK.

Dr. Don is NOT responsible for any consequences for any advice given here that is followed by you as the reader. The advice is only meant as an opinion and observation.

____________________________________________

What is the point of this blog?

The purpose of this blog is to provide some simple opinions and pseudo advice into anything that you the reader may want on any situation, questions or observations.

If there are no posts below, it is because no-one has asked anything.

Please feel free to ask your questions by e-mailing them to dr.dchiou@gmail.com and I will respond with the question and response with any personal identifiers removed from it. Otherwise, please leave your question anon in the comment box below.

There may be other posts that are pieces of general advice that I have felt like sharing.

For my own history and experiences, please see the box in the sidebar about me.

I hope to read from you all soon.
*******************************************************

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Bacterial Resistance?

EDIT: The following is probably wrong! I have been informed by someone that it is something to do with genetic mutation. But I'll still leave what I said below because it sounded good :D

DISCLAIMER!

I am not a molecular biologist or pharmacologist/toxicologist etc. This following answer/conversation is from my knowledge and understanding of cells and systems.


Miss X says:
Don
Miss X says:
can i ask you a question
Miss X says:
about bacterial resistance
Don says:
uh, you can
Don says:
but I don't know how good my answer will be
Miss X says:
why is it use combination therapy will minimise the emergence of resistant (in HIV not bacteria)
Miss X says:
combination therapy wil give synergistic effect
Miss X says:
but how does it reduce the resistant
Don says:
because the bateria has to develop resistance to more than 1 thing
Miss X says:
oh
Miss X says:
hmmm
Don says:
the baterial cells have to spend more energy than it has to develop multiple resistances
Don says:
while singular treatments means the bacteria only has to develop resistance to one type of attack to it
Miss X says:
ok
Miss X says:
then another question
Don says:
that would be my understanding
Miss X says:
gram positive bacteria secrete beta lactamase to the environment surrounding cell, but gram negative secrete the lactamse within the cell enviroment...
Miss X says:
so how does gram negative bacteria develop more resistance to beta lactam antibiotics?
Miss X says:
intact environemnt will contribute to more resitance?
Don says:
well, I don't know what latamse is
Miss X says:
because the environemnt is not changing?
Miss X says:
its an enzyme
Don says:
what does it do?
Miss X says:
antiobiotics attack that enzyme to kill the bacteria
Don says:
no no
Don says:
what does the cell secrete
Miss X says:
beta lactamase enzyme
Don says:
yes
Don says:
but what does the enzyme do
Don says:
the bateria isn't going to secrete something that kills itself
Miss X says:
beta lactamase form the bacterial cell wall
Miss X says:
beta lactam antibiotic hydrolyse the beta lactamase, so cell wall cannot form, therefore bactrial cell death
Don says:
ok
Don says:
so then what is the "cell environment"
Don says:
ie, what is the difference between outside/inside the "environment"
Miss X says:
gram negative got extra outer membrane on top of the cell wall
Miss X says:
to prevent the beta lactamase to be secreted to the outer environment
Don says:
there is your answer
Don says:
it has an extra membrane that is not lactamase
Don says:
therefore antiobiotics that are lactamase specific first have to penetrate the membrane
Miss X says:
then why resistance develop more rapidly in gram negative
Miss X says:
than in gram positive
Miss X says:
antibiotic resistance
Don says:
because less antiobotics penetrate the membrane
Don says:
so there is not enough antibiotic to kill the cell fast enough and it develops resistance
Don says:
because it doesn't get through the membrane fast enough to lyse the cell contents
Miss X says:
oh ok
Don says:
think of resistance = immune system
Miss X says:
hmmmmmmmmmm
Don says:
we get vaccinations as humans
Don says:
our immune systems form antibodies from vaccinations because vaccinations are weak versions of the actual illness
Don says:
so, a cell that gets a weak (or low dose) amount of an antigen, will form its own antibody against it
Don says:
so when a membrane protects the cell from the influx of a large amount of antigen, it has opportunity to form antibody, thus resistance
Don says:
that is how I would interpret it
Miss X says:
so... gram positive and negative both develop resistant at same rate
Miss X says:
but gram positive get killed by antibiotics faster
Don says:
you can't make the assumption that they make it at the same rate
Don says:
it just doesn't have the opportunity to make it because there may be too much antibody for it to react soon enough
Miss X says:
hmmm
Miss X says:
ok
Miss X says:
i understand now
Miss X says:
thx Don
Miss X says:
[smiley]
Don says:
no problems

No comments:

Post a Comment